Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Red Beet Eggs

I want to explore the wold of pickled eggs, pickled beets, and the combination of pickled eggs and beets. I want to shed some light on various recipes and provide a favorite pickled egg recipe, called Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Red Beet Eggs.

Some local (Pennsylvania) readers may see the title of this post, the above picture, and below recipe and not bat an eye. I am sure most Pennsylvanians, especially those near Amish country, are very familiar with the wonderful purple and yellow visual of a halved red beet egg. However, what may come as a surprise to those readers is that this purple wonder is not ubiquitous around the nation. The term pickled egg, in the mid-Atlantic region may conjure images of a purple egg, but that isn’t the case for much of the nation. Even more interesting, where pickled eggs are purple, they don’t share the same name. It’s also important to know that pickled egg recipes tend to be different in many regions, only some of which end up purple, or more specifically, include beets.

There are a number of names for pickled red beet eggs. However, purple eggs are not well distributed throughout the country. Here you can see three common names and the states where they are most common.
The popularity of the different names for pickled eggs and beets, by the numbers, is pretty similar.

Pickled Beets

This article and recipe isn’t about beets or pickled beets specifically. Pickled beets are a popular canned good all over the country. However, you can’t have red beet eggs without beets. In some recipes, you can simply add hard boiled eggs together with pickled beets in a jar, allow them to hang out in the fridge for a week and the end result will be pickled red beet eggs. However, the recipe I like to use calls for beets that aren’t yet pickled. Making the pickling brine is part of the recipe and gives you a bit more control over the flavor. However, whether pickled or not, growing and harvesting your own beets is certainly an option. Pickling and canning those beets could really speed up your pickled beets and egg recipe. Simply mix your pickled beets with hard boiled eggs in a jar and you are good to go.

Growing, harvesting, canning, and pickling beets could be the first step to a great pickled red beet egg.

Pickled Eggs

Pickled eggs don’t need to be purple. Historically, when I think of pickled eggs, I go to a beet based recipe in my mind. However, even in Pennsylvania, not all pickled eggs include beets. There are plenty of pickled egg recipes which don’t include beets. If you aren’t a fan of beets, you can get a similar result without the earthy beet flavor and without the purple color. A simple recipe for a pickled egg:

Pickled Egg Recipe

12 Hard Boiled Eggs
2 Cups Vinegar (I prefer apple cider vinegar in sweet pickled eggs and white vinegar in unsweetened pickled eggs.)
Up to 1 Cup Water
1/2 Cup Sugar (Or not if you don’t want them sweet)
2 Tablespoons Pickling spice

Without sugar I tend to like a bit more vinegar, you could add 1 more cup of vinegar. I wouldn’t go beyond a 3 to 1 ratio of vinegar to water or below a 2 to 1 ratio. Without sugar, add 2 tablespoons of salt and some dill, garlic, and/or black Pepper to taste (1 teaspoon of one or all would be a good starting point.)

You will need enough Water to cover the eggs if the brine doesn’t cover them (Note the ratios above.)

Other optional ingredients:
Jalapeno peppers (Halved, seeds included or not depending upon heat. Or, use a hotter pepper to really add some heat.)
Onion (1 Coarsely chopped)
Bay Leaves (2)

How To Make Pickled Eggs

Try everything together, sugar, salt, and all the options!

Mix all ingredients, minus the eggs, in a sauce pan. You can heat it to help the sugars dissolve, but don’t boil it.

Add eggs to large container (A gallon jar works well.)

Pour the brine over the eggs and allow them to rest in the brine in the refrigerator for at least a few days.

I would eat them within a month.

If you are unaware, pickling spice is sold in pre-mixed packages.

Pickled Beets Versus Pickled Eggs

Not only are there differences in the names used for red beet eggs, but pickled beets versus pickled eggs is its own story. I can’t say for sure why pickled beets may be more popular than pickled eggs, or vice versa. It is most likely, like many regional differences, simply a mix of culture and climate.

Pickled beets alone have more popularity in the north and north west of the country while  pickled eggs win the contest in the east and south.
Pickled beets and pickled eggs tend to be close in popularity by the numbers.

Red Beet Eggs

Now, this is where I want to drop a bombshell! Red beet eggs are not traditionally “pickled eggs.” Red beet eggs, as they are known to the Pennsylvania Dutch, are simply that, hard boiled eggs mixed with red beets. They are allowed to commingle for a period of time and the end result is a mild, beet flavored purple egg. Often, there is salt included as the desire for preservation still exists, but not vinegar or sugar and spices. The fact that these red beet eggs exist can be a bit of a surprise if you are accustomed to a pickled version. The pickling brine, including vinegar, sugar, and pickling spice, really adds a lot of new flavors to the hard boiled eggs. If you really enjoy beets and don’t want a strong pickled flavor, simply mix some beets and their juice with some eggs, add some salt (About a teaspoon per cup of beets/juice), give it some time, and presto, Red Beet Eggs. These would keep for a while even without refrigeration.

What seems to be troubling to me is that some recipes for red beet eggs, while not including the “pickled” adjective, still create a pickling brine. This may be due to misunderstanding or potentially due to long standing family tradition in some circles. However, let me be clear, a red beet egg and a pickled red beet egg are two separate hard boiled egg recipes.

Pickled Eggs And Beets

Whether you know them as Pickled Beet Eggs, Pickled Red Beet Eggs, or simply Pickled Eggs And Beets, the recipes all tend to be similar. This recipe is mostly designed to preserve eggs beyond their standard shelf life and tends to be quick and easy. There are some recipes that try to get fancy, and that is always an option. However, if you have some eggs that need to be used and you want a quick way to add another month or two to their life, these Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Red Beet Eggs are your answer.

How To Make Pickled Eggs

How To Make Pickled Eggs
The list of ingredients is short. That makes this pickled egg recipe quick and easy.

1-2 Dozen Hard Boiled Eggs
Beets – 2 cans or 1 quart
Vinegar – 2 Cups
Sugar – 3 Cups
Pickling Spice – 1 Tablespoon (Add another Tablespoon for a richer flavor)

How To Make Pickled Red Beet Eggs

1. Hard Boil the eggs. If you need some help here, please visit the how to hard boil eggs guide
2. Drain the beet juice into a sauce pan.

Pickled Egg Recipe
Beet juice in a sauce pan.

3. Add Vinegar, Sugar, and Spice to the pan.

Pickled Beets Recipe
Making a pickle brine for pickled red beet eggs.

4. Mix your eggs and beets together in a jar.

Pickled Beet Eggs
Pickled beets and eggs.
Pickled Eggs And Beets
Layering eggs and beets allows the beets and eggs to commingle best.

5. Pour the pickling brine over the layered hard boiled eggs and beets.

Red Beet Eggs
Layered hard boiled eggs and beets.
Pickled Red Beet Eggs
Pickled red beet eggs.

Hard Boiled Eggs And Beer

This wouldn’t be Jerky, Pickles, and Beer without some mention of pairing hard boiled eggs and beer. The sweet and sour pickling brine and the earthy flavor of beets compliments beer very well.

Pickled Hard Boiled Eggs And Beer
Pickled hard boiled eggs and beer are a great combination.

If you are simply interested in Pennsylvania Dutch traditions, you can purchase pickled red beet eggs from a famous Lancaster County producer:

Also, no kitchen is complete without a gallon glass jar or two.

1 thought on “Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Red Beet Eggs”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *